Scruton's Preferences

My second question is whether or not Scruton ranks certain forms of contemporary music superior to other contemporary forms, or if he just ranks all contemporary music as equally inferior to classical music. For example, he could dislike rap music even more than he dislikes rock music.

Although I could never be sure without actually asking Scruton, I do believe that there are some forms of contemporary music that he would believe to be more acceptable than other forms. As I stated in my previous blog, I do not believe Scruton bases his judgments solely on the time period in which certain music is popular. He bases his judgments on the quality and complexity of the music at hand. Therefore, I can't really say that he would prefer, in my opinion, music from a certain decade over music from another decade. I can't say that he would probably prefer the music of the 1980's over the music of the 2000's. That would imply that he is judging music based on the time in which it was produced. He just believes that music has a tendency to decline in quality and complexity as more time goes by. He believes this is just an accurate, negative correlation.

I can, however, say that Scruton might prefer one genre over another. In my question, I said as an example that maybe Scruton prefers contemporary rock over contemporary rap music. I am not claiming that this is true, but it very well could be the case. Scruton could claim that rap is far too simple compared to classical music to be considered "good" music. He might claim that rap music doesn't have harmony, melody, tone and rhythm. It might have some, but not all of these characteristics. He might prefer rock music because at least most rock artists use musical instruments.  

In class, we discussed how some contemporary music incorporates orchestras into their music. We discussed whether or not Scruton would enjoy this type of music. I believe that although he might not consider this kind of music something breathtaking, he would probably appreciate it at least somewhat. For example, the song "Bittersweet Symphony" by the British band the Verve incorporates an orchestra into its performance. Although I have a feeling that Scruton would definitely have some critiques about how repetitive the violin is, I do believe he would at least somewhat appreciate this song.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-p7h2ANRsk
^ "Bittersweet Symphony" by the Verve, live on BBC Television